Whether you’re in email marketing or transactional sending, achieving a successful message delivery happens way in advance before the intended message reaches the inbox at all. But for many senders, SMTP authentication errors come into play as the first line of defense and failure. SMTP authentication errors prevent your email from sending in the first place, putting a serious roadblock in your way on your day-of sending and messaging endeavors. Thus, knowing how to resolve SMTP auth error issues is paramount to successful email exchanges before they even happen.
What Are SMTP Authentication Errors and Why Do They Matter?
Table of Contents
SMTP authentication errors occur when, during the sending process, the email client or sending server can’t properly authenticate with the outgoing mail server. Authentication means verifying the identity of who is trying to send mail through a specific server. If that mail server does not believe that the person trying to send mail is allowed to, it revokes the ability to send mail altogether although it never actually gets into the outbound queue. This is different from a soft bounce or an SMTP error that occurs because of the content of the message being sent; this is rejection first and this rejection occurs before the message even drops into the outbound queue.
Authentication is a critical component of email registration and sending and a part of a new, complicated layered security for mail systems since spam and phishing are at an all-time high. Therefore, as an anti-spam measure, many mail servers want the extra step to ensure that someone is not trying to do something illegitimate with access that shouldn’t be there. “535 Authentication failed” and “530 Authentication required” are just two examples of SMTP authentication errors, which mean that your credentials did not align with what the mail server wanted, and your email was not sent. SMTP error 451.432 may also arise during authentication if the server temporarily defers your message due to rate limits or other policy enforcement mechanisms, even when credentials are correct.
Common Causes of SMTP Authentication Failures
There are many reasons why SMTP authentication fails, some are more critical to the ability to function than others. For example, one of the most common mistakes is the failure to use the username and password correctly. Ensuring that the username is misspelled or that the password is outdated prevents the client from being aligned with the mail server.
Configuration is another common mistake. The client does not have the authentication option flagged (STARTTLS, SSL), or it is not selected when the mail server requires it one way or the other. In addition, if the client has port 25 when the mail server would allow 587, this is a problem (port 25 denies anyone not authenticated and allows a collision).
IP restrictions are another reason; some mail servers will only allow authenticated requests from predetermined IP addresses. Therefore, if the sending IP is not a part of the authenticated trusted list, it will deny the request even if the user has the correct information.
Diagnosing Authentication Errors in Your Mail Logs
When SMTP authentication fails, the error message returned by the server often has the necessary information to troubleshoot the issue. For example, “535 5.7.8 Authentication credentials invalid” communicates which password or username is incorrect, and “530 5.7.0 Must issue a STARTTLS command first” indicates failure due to an incorrect command for those with encryption features.
In addition, the error happens in most email clients and servers. For example, one’s email service provider or mail server dashboard contains such errors at some time when anyone has attempted to send such authentication. This is helpful for either changes in settings or when communicating with customer support to understand why failures occur.
Fixing SMTP Authentication Errors Step-by-Step
There are several ways to troubleshoot SMTP authentication failures. For example, make sure your username and password are both correct. Your username will be the email address from which you’re attempting to send. If the wrong password is assigned to that email address, ensure the corresponding client (i.e., Outlook or Thunderbird) uses the same username/password combination for outbound access. Also, make sure other SMTP configurations like SMTP server name and port reflect what’s been configured on your mail server and what’s expected by the mail server.
In addition, check your application or code to ensure that it allows for authentication if required by your mail server. For example, many mail clients have a checkbox that says “My outgoing server requires authentication.” If this is unchecked, the code will fail to send messages. In addition, one can verify login credentials via an SMTP telnet or command line which tests whether or not authentication works independently of your application. This can indicate if the application in question is at fault or if there is something wrong on your end with your SMTP service.
How Authentication Errors Affect Email Marketing and Business Communication
SMTP authentication errors may be esoteric, but the impact is at a business level beyond IT. At best, if authentication fails, delivery fails your email doesn’t even get off the ground, let alone into an inbox. Every email that fails to go is an email that loses a subsequent opportunity: a welcome email for a new subscriber, a confirmation email for an order just processed, a highly detailed email pitch that can ultimately convert. Within industries where every second counts ecommerce, finance, and healthcare a single email that fails when all could have changed the outcome means lost revenue, frustrated clients, and, in some cases, compliance violations when emails are mandated.
But that chance increases exponentially when you’re sending high volumes of email marketing blasts. For instance, a 2–5% bounce rate isn’t the end of the world until your company is sending thousands and thousands of emails, and 2–5% translates into thousands of people who never get your email. That’s thousands of missed clicks, absent CTAs, and people who could be lost customers and engagement, all of which easily sums up to thousands of dollars.
Even worse, however, is that when these failures go unnoticed or even unresolved they compound against your marketing ROI, fooling you into thinking something’s wrong with your campaign. Beyond deliverability, consistent failures with SMTP authentication occur as well, which signals poorly to the state of your more extensive email operation. For instance, domains that don’t match, incorrect SMTP credentials, and outdated authentication like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC have long-term results on your sender’s reputation.
Ultimately, ISPs and mailbox providers assess sender reputation as a trust measure as to whether or not they should allow your email to go to the inbox or be delayed and/or placed into spam. The longer it takes to deliver to the intended recipient, even if it ultimately gets there, the more errors and failures associated with the sender’s domain complicate credibility for future campaign delivery success. In addition, authentication errors increase the likelihood of your domain being spoofed or used for phishing.
When SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are absent or inappropriately adjusted, ill-intentioned third parties will attempt to use breached accounts to send messages in a fraudulent capacity, acting as if they’re representatives of your brand to garner sensitive data from unaware recipients regardless of the pop-ups they may receive. This not only jeopardizes your brand’s integrity, but your brand faces potential legal or compliance issues depending upon the sensitive data that was rendered during this phishing activity. The bottom line is that when your domain is authenticated, it lets the receiving servers know that only those authorized can legitimately correspond with the brand.
Ultimately, neglecting SMTP authentication errors will be seen as just an arbitrary technicality, but as time goes on, companies that fall behind because they do not account for email authentication will find themselves behind those who include email authentication as part of their communication security best practices. Thus, all the time and money spent to set up, troubleshoot, and continually assess the authentication systems is worth it in the end for better deliverability, better brand preservation, better recipient experiences, and better certainty for both marketing and IT that allow them to scale without hidden frictions that undelivered messages can cause.
Preventing Authentication Issues Before They Start
SMTP authentication problems occur when they happen, so avoid them. Start with a consistent sending situation. Print out or electronically save the email settings used within the company so everyone has the same information and never change SMTP passwords without informing all clients and services relying upon them.
Furthermore, save SMTP passwords in encrypted folders in addition to easy folders with access for certain individuals, use two-factor authentication any time it is possible, and attempt to change passwords often to keep unsuspecting individuals from gaining access to email accounts.
When team members are onboarded, make them aware of how to set up SMTP on their own, all server names, settings, ports, SSL/TLS, etc., should be provided. The same goes for onboarding a new ESP. They, too, require the proper instructions to set things up correctly.
Finally, for those who need to send many emails, purchase dedicated IP addresses and managed services associated with them for extra assistance and monitoring, which may catch a problem sooner and facilitate better practices.
Conclusion: SMTP Authentication as the Foundation of Reliable Email Delivery
SMTP authentication errors are fairly minor configurations, though they have to do with the trust of email security’s very foundation. In fact, without them, the state of email systems in 2023 will deny you access to not only send your intended message and have it lost in cyberspace but instead, receive bounce-back messages or, even worse, land in a spam folder or, more likely, the never-seen category promotions and never get seen at all. Thus, as email becomes more prevalent and associated email crime spikes, email service providers have become stricter and stricter, requiring would-be senders to prove their identity and intended email usage. SMTP authentication is the starting line at the race your domain and IP address proclaiming your right to send.
This isn’t a problem for businesses to sweep under the rug; it’s a business concern. Busy email interfaces are often the first line of customer acquisition efforts, customer service efforts, order confirmation, and brand loyalty efforts. Whether you are a small Shopify store with a limited number of promotional email blasts or an international corporation operating multiple sub-brands with prominent email campaigns to hundreds of thousands of people, your operation’s ability to convey communication relies upon an operational email system.
When everything seems to go right, you’d think that configuring an SMTP would be a simple process; it’s not. One typo in the SMTP password, an incorrect port, or a poorly configured domain policy results in a nightmare. Emails bounce or fail to send, and important information fails to reach customers; your brand’s reputation suffers as the email client thinks your business is noncompliant to best practices and simply spam.
Fortunately, the SMTP authentication concern is preventable and resolvable, especially when you know best practices for now and in the future. As long as you are always on the lookout checking error logs and bounce reports for signs of invalid login attempts, inaccessible relay features, and DNS issues you should be able to detect SMTP problems before they lead to disastrous failures. For example, bounce reports and error logs can easily inform you of what needs to be changed in your SMTP settings while also providing the information necessary to resolve the issue quickly.
The ability to diagnose such issues in real time is critical. Authentication issues don’t go away on their own, and if a sender is continuously failing to authenticate, their sender reputation is negatively impacted over time. Thus, with the ability to access SMTP testers, authentication record checkers, and, in some situations, access to mail server logs, senders can troubleshoot and remediate errors quickly before they taint an email campaign. The sooner the better; the less damage incurred and the more trust established with end users and mail server providers.
In addition, the ability to take preventative measures, secured SMTP settings, two-factor authentication, periodically changed credentials, adherence to SPF, DKIM, and DMARC adds a level of protection and trustworthiness. When mail providers note that you’re trying to be a trusted sender, they will be less likely to raise flagging issues down the line and overall deliverability increases.
In the end, SMTP authentication is not merely a task to be completed; it’s essential for professional, consistent communication with every email sent and received. Proper SMTP authentication ensures that your email can navigate the extensive information superhighway to arrive at its final stop at your receiver’s inbox, where it will build trust, generate feedback, and improve your online brand presence.
